I have not read the review yet, however, having previously had a RRS 3.0 and I do think that overall, I prefer the F Pace - albeit because my priorities are slightly different.
My requirements are for something that is fun to drive, relatively quick, handles well and comfortable for long journeys. The RRS, in my opinion, is more refined, has a better overall ride and is supreme on the mundane, motorway schleps. Whilst it is fun in it's own right, the level of understeer is much more noticeable, the extra weight can also be felt in faster corners and the car has a greater degree of roll. The interior quality is, again in my opinion, at a much higher level than the F Pace - the plastics, leather and overall build are to a higher standard.
The F Pace interior, whilst not to the same quality standard, is a very nice place to be, and more modern in both architecture and technology. When it comes to handling and driving characteristics, I prefer the ability to balance the car on the throttle do dial out the understeer, I also prefer the sound of the 3.0D, which although more noticeable, has a lovely growl to it that the RRS lacks.
In tighter corners, it is possible to drift the FP and encourage a little oversteer (Trac DSC) whilst still keeping everything calm and controlled. The RRS will drift if really pushed, but it is a full 4 wheel drift, that whilst controllable, is not becoming and lacks decorum - the F Pace is a bit more hooligan!
The other contributing factor to choosing the F Pace rather than another RRS, was that nearly everyone I know, and certainly here in Harrogate, a large proportion of RRS's appear to be in residence!
I have omitted the Macan comparison because the amount of time I have had behind the wheel is limited. My recollections however, were of a supremely well crafted cabin which looked bland, a great engine - nice sound, excellent performance and free revving. The handling was very sports car like - better than the F Pace, however the ride was brittle, and although the handling was ultimately sharper, it lacked a sense of fun the the F pace has. Also, I don't think I could live with the looks!
Perhaps I should share the F Pace with "The Enemy" buy a F Type, or perhaps a nice 2014 Italian Racing Red XKR-S that is sitting at a nearby Jaguar dealer - I still regret selling my previous XKR-S more than any other car I have had!